this blog has moved to a new address:

Please update your RSS, bookmarks, and links to

Tuesday, January 31, 2006

did the "west" really "want in?"

Some people would suggest that the "West" has more than one political ideology in some ridiculous attempt to paint the "West" as anything but a monolithic Conservative homogeny! :-P

Here's a short exert from the most excellent recent edition of Mark Lisac's Insight into Government publication:

"The Conservatives won the most seats in each of the four western provinces and picked up enough in Ontario and Quebec to give them the biggest representation in the House of Commons 124 seats out of 308.

Look closer and it isn’t so simple.

Albertans voted 65% Conservative and gave the party every seat in the province.

In Manitoba and Saskatchewan, the Conservatives took the most seats but the popular vote was a saw-off; the Conservatives won a three-way split with less than half the popular vote. The split was even more pronounced in British Columbia, where the Conservatives won 17 of 36 seats with 37.3% of the popular vote.

Alberta is in. The rural Prairies and the B.C. Interior are in. The West as a whole is far too complex for simplistic characterization. Big parts of the region don’t look much different from the rest of the country.

The results in B.C. closely matched those in Ontario, where the Conservatives won 35.1% of the popular vote. Ontario is just as much Conservative country as B.C., and B.C. is just as much Liberal and NDP country as Ontario. In fact, the Conservatives picked up a bigger share of votes in Toronto (23.8%) than they did in Vancouver (22.1%).

All the people talking about the West have to define more closely what they think the West means. The arrival of westerners in government has one huge symbolic effect: Alberta and the Prairies can enjoy an emotional sense of recognition a feeling that they count. The election as whole delivered other, perhaps even stronger messages: the separatist cause in Quebec faltered, thanks to the Conservatives hard work; the divergence between rural and urban interests deepened; Canadians demonstrated once again a preference for balanced representation by at least five parties, a message the politicians may gradually and grudgingly have to accept."

Mark Lisac is also the author of Alberta Politics Uncovered: Taking Back our Province, which we highly recommend to anyone interested in Alberta politics.


Michael Fox said...

How dare you.

daveberta said...

"How dare you."

How dare I what?

Emilio said...

The interior of BC and Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba for me are all considered the west. Of course people in BC resemble people in California in terms of pot smoking and partyers. But there are differences between the west and say the east or central Canada although these may now be changing with the election of Stephen Harper.
One would be the gun registry which is not supported by people in the prairies and I assume the entire interior of BC except the west coast. The registry is a Liberal idiotic attempt to control guns and it didn't work if we look at Toronto's killing spree. Banning all hand-guns! What a stupid Liberal attempt to stop something which is already illegal to own. The only people to support such a measure live in Canada's three biggest cities. The premier of Manitoba and Saskatchewan both will not honor this ban if it passed and these are NDP governments. Of course Dalton McGuinty will but he has the ideology of Central Canada. 3rd is being anti-American. I simply dont hear it as much in the west as I do from people like David Miller, the mayor of Toronto who says its their fault for all our gun problems since he is so incompetent and weak on crime. B/c its really Americans who are coming across the border and killing innocent people. I think Paul Martin's anti-american rants and ads were aimed at central Canada and the maritimes to win votes yet it backfired slightly this time b/c people are sick of it. Of course the Liberals still won 103 seats so obviously there must be a strong anti-american sentiment in some of these ridings. Take Carolyn Parrish's riding.
Granted now the CPC is in power and alot of these feelings may change but I'm talking about the past 12 years of Liberal rule which contributed to my feelings of western alienation and alot of other fellow Albertans I know. However we all feel alot more patriotic now that we have our own as PM!